Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

Why Might Your Home Insurance Policy Be Non-Renewed for An Old Roof, and Can Manufacturer-Backed Warranties Help?

August , 2024 | 13 min. read

By Anthony Marzbanian

Inspection day Fail over a tile roof

Are you a homeowner who received a non-renewal notice from your insurance company? Claiming your roof is too old. You're not alone.

We understand how unsettling it can be to deal with the uncertainty of an insurance policy cancellation.

Now the BIG question here is, Why do roofing companies offer these extended manufacturer-backed warranties if the insurance companies will make us replace our roof before the warranty expires?

Insurance companies aren't necessarily focused on the age of your roof but on what it does for your home. A well-maintained roof, even one 15-25 years old, can prevent severe damage during a weather event and save you and your insurer from hefty repair bills.

Our family at RoofCrafters has been helping homeowners navigate these challenges for over 30 years. We've seen firsthand how a well-maintained roof can stop severe damage and prevent high-cost insurance claims. We also know that having an older roof doesn't mean it won't protect your home. And it may not need replacing to keep your homeowners' insurance policy current either!

This guide will explain why your insurance policy might not be renewed. It will explain specific laws and rights you have as a homeowner. It will also show how a manufacturer-backed warranty can protect you and give you longterm peace of mind.

Let's dive right in.

Understanding Insurance Non-Renewal for Older Roofs

 

As a homeowner, an insurance non-renewal notice can be confusing and stressful. Insurance companies care less about your roof's age than about its job. It must protect your home. Your roof is your home's first defense against harsh weather. It protects both its structure and your valuable belongings.

inspection photo of a roofer and homeowner

As your roof ages, it protects less. This can cause serious issues, like water damage. Water damage is a big problem. It can cause mold growth. This is very costly for insurance companies to fix. Mold remediation can cost thousands of dollars, far outweighing the cost of replacing an aging roof. A timely roof replacement can prevent severe damage and high remediation costs.

roofing estimator inspecting a cornice return on a ladder

Insurance companies aim to reduce risks. They want the homes they cover to be well-maintained. This makes them less likely to suffer extensive damage in severe weather. Insurance companies need homeowners to maintain or replace old roofs. This protects them from costly claims. It also ensures your home is safe and secure.

Let's explore why insurance companies cancel policies for roofs 10-15 years old. We'll also look at the impact on homeowners.

Why Insurance Companies Cancel Policies for 10-15-Year-Old Roofs

 

To understand why insurers cancel policies for roofs 10-15 years old, we must consider the risks of aging roofs. As roofs age, they wear out. This can reduce their ability to protect your home. This increased risk means more claims for the insurer if a severe weather event should occur. So, older roofs are a big liability.

estimator taking photo

Insurance companies usually set an age limit for roofs. They won't renew policies beyond this limit. The roof must be inspected and certified to have at least 5 years of useful life left. This practice helps insurers manage risk. It ensures they do not insure properties likely to suffer major damage and costly claims.

The Value of Manufacturer-Backed Warranties

 

A manufacturer-backed warranty is a guarantee from the roof material maker. It covers both the materials and the work to install the roof. This warranty gives homeowners added peace of mind. It protects their roof against defects and potential issues that may arise over time. It also guarantees no leaks for up to 25 and 30 years with certain products.

Coverage Provided by Manufacturer-Backed Warranties:

  1. Material Coverage: This part of the warranty ensures that the roofing materials used are free from manufacturing defects. If any issues arise due to material faults, the manufacturer will cover the cost of repairs or replacements.

  2. Workmanship Coverage: This covers any installation errors or workmanship defects that could compromise the roof's integrity. If problems occur due to poor installation practices, the manufacturer will be responsible for addressing these issues.

Long-Term Benefits of Manufacturer-Backed Warranties:

  1. Extended Protection: Manufacturer-backed warranties often offer extended coverage periods, sometimes lasting 50 years or more. This long-term protection ensures that homeowners do not have to worry about unexpected roofing costs for a significant portion of their roof's lifespan.

  2. Peace of Mind: Knowing that both materials and workmanship are covered provides homeowners with peace of mind. They can rest assured that any defects or issues will be addressed by the manufacturer, reducing the financial burden and stress associated with roof repairs.

  3. Increased Home Value: A roof with a manufacturer-backed warranty can increase a home's value. Prospective buyers will appreciate the added security and potential cost savings, making the property more attractive on the market.

Strengths and Weaknesses of Manufacturer-Backed Warranties:

 

Warranty Strengths:

  • Comprehensive Coverage: These warranties provide comprehensive coverage, ensuring both materials and workmanship are guaranteed.

  • Extended Duration: The warranties often last longer than standard contractor warranties, offering protection for an extended period.

  • Manufacturer Support: Homeowners enjoy the support and resources of established manufacturers, ensuring reliable service and resolution of any issues.

Warranty Weaknesses:

  • Claim Process: The process of filing a claim can be stringent and may need thorough documentation and inspections.

  • Exclusions and Limitations: Some warranties may have exclusions or limitations, such as coverage only for specific types of damage or requirements for regular maintenance.

  • Transferability: While some warranties are transferable to new homeowners, others may not be, which can affect the property's resale value.

In conclusion, manufacturer-backed warranties greatly benefit homeowners. They provide long-term protection and peace of mind. For more detailed information check out our article on manufacturer-backed warranties.

Addressing Common Questions About Warranties and Insurance Requirements

 

Homeowners often ask, "Why buy an extended manufacturer's warranty?" My insurer will force me to replace my roof in 15 years."

This is a valid concern. Right?

However, there may be good reasons to invest in a manufacturer-backed warranty that would help you with the insurance requirements and provide you peace of mind from costly roof repairs.

Benefits of Having a Manufacturer-Backed Warranty:

  1. Comprehensive Coverage: Manufacturer-backed warranties cover both materials and workmanship. This means that if there are any defects or issues with the roofing materials or the installation process, the manufacturer will address them. This comprehensive coverage can save you from significant out-of-pocket expenses and ensure that your roof remains in top condition throughout its lifespan.

  2. Extended Protection: Unlike standard contractor warranties, manufacturer-backed warranties often offer extended coverage periods, sometimes up to 50 years. This extended protection ensures that you are covered for a longer duration, providing peace of mind and financial security.

  3. Influence on Insurance Decisions: Having a manufacturer-backed warranty can positively influence your insurance company's decisions. When your roof is certified to be in good condition and has an extended warranty, your insurance company may be forced to renew your policy. This is because the warranty indicates that the roof is less likely to suffer from significant issues, reducing the insurer's risk. 

  4. Potential Legal Protections: In some states, like Florida, laws such as Senate Bill 76 provide legal protections for homeowners with certified roofs. These laws prevent insurance companies from non-renewing policies based solely on the roof's age if it has been certified to have a useful life remaining. While Georgia and South Carolina may not have identical laws, the trend toward such protections is growing, and having a certified warranty can be a crucial factor in maintaining your coverage. Check out: Insurance Journal.

  5. Peace of Mind and Increased Home Value: A manufacturer-backed warranty offers peace of mind, knowing that both materials and workmanship are covered. This warranty can also increase your home's value, making it more attractive to potential buyers who will appreciate the added security and potential cost savings.

Why You Still Need a Manufacturer-Backed Warranty:

 

A 15-year roof replacement policy may exist with your insurer. But, a warranty from the manufacturer offers vital benefits. It keeps your roof in top shape, reducing costly roof leak repairs. It can also affect your insurance renewal. The warranty can help you contest any early non-renewal notices due to the roof's age. Preventing you from incurring unnecessary costs prematurely. 

RoofCrafters supervisor inspecting crews work

A warranty from the manufacturer protects your home and finances. It gives you peace of mind. It helps reduce your insurance investment. It also protects your most valuable asset—your home. 

Legal Protections for Homeowners with Manufacturer-Backed Warranties

 

Homeowners with manufacturer warranties have unique legal protections. They can help safeguard their investment. They ensure their roofs are covered by insurance. Understanding these protections is important for homeowners.

Because we service the Southeast region we will focus on South Carolina. Georgia, and Florida.

Florida Laws

In Florida, Senate Bill 76 offers significant legal protections for homeowners with manufacturer-backed warranties. This legislation mandates that insurance companies cannot refuse to issue or renew a homeowners insurance policy based solely on the age of the roof if the roof has been inspected and certified to have at least five years of useful life remaining. This law helps ensure that homeowners with well-maintained roofs are not unfairly penalized due to the roof's age.

Georgia Laws

Georgia has also taken steps to protect homeowners from unfair insurance practices. According to Georgia Code § 33-24-46, insurers must provide valid reasons for non-renewal and allow homeowners the opportunity to address the issues cited. If an insurer attempts to non-renew a policy based on the age of the roof, homeowners can request a detailed explanation and contest the decision if they believe it to be unjust. Recently, the Georgia Insurance Commissioner intervened when Farmers Insurance attempted to non-renew policies for homes with roofs over 15 years old, citing a violation of state law and requiring the company to rescind these notices​  

South Carolina Laws

While South Carolina does not have as specific statutes addressing roof age and insurance non-renewals as Florida, homeowners still have recourse through general insurance regulations. The South Carolina Department of Insurance provides guidelines for homeowners to challenge non-renewal notices and can offer mediation services. Homeowners facing non-renewal due to the age of their roof should contact the department directly to explore their options and ensure their rights are protected. 

The Importance of Manufacturer-Backed Warranties

Manufacturer-backed warranties can play an important role in these legal contexts. These warranties can help homeowners meet state laws and insurers' requirements. They certify that the roof is in good condition and has a long useful life. It can stop unfair policy cancellations and ensure coverage.

A young family of four standing in front of a cartoon home drawn on a backdrop, image of flowers, clouds, and the sun too.

Also, these warranties often have legal protections. They hold manufacturers accountable for any material defects or workmanship issues. This coverage protects homeowners from surprise costs. It keeps their homes well-protected and in top condition.

How RoofCrafters Can Help Protect Your Investment

 

Protecting your investment in your home starts with ensuring your roof is in top condition. RoofCrafters has the skills and services to maintain your roof. We can help you meet insurance requirements. We can also provide top-of-the-line manufacturer-backed warranties.

View the Roof Warranty Guide

We also provide the following services:

Comprehensive Roof Inspections

Regular roof inspections are crucial for identifying potential issues before they become significant problems. Our team of experienced professionals conducts thorough inspections to assess the condition of your roof, identify any areas of concern, and provide detailed reports. These inspections are essential for maintaining your roof's integrity and ensuring it meets the standards required by your insurance policy.

Expert Roof Replacement Services

When it's time for a roof replacement, you can trust RoofCrafters to deliver high-quality workmanship and durable materials. We specialize in replacing aging roofs with top-of-the-line products that come with manufacturer-backed warranties. This ensures your new roof is not only built to last but also provides the extended protection and peace of mind that come with comprehensive warranty coverage.

Roof Warranty Protection

Manufacturer-backed warranties offer significant benefits for homeowners, including coverage for both materials and workmanship. At RoofCrafters, we work with the top roofing brands to provide warranties that protect your investment for the long term. These warranties can also play a crucial role in maintaining your insurance coverage, as they demonstrate that your roof is in excellent condition and less likely to suffer from defects or damage.

Help Navigating Insurance Requirements

Understanding and meeting insurance requirements can be challenging, but RoofCrafters is here to help. Our team is well-versed in the latest insurance regulations and can assist you in navigating the complexities of policy renewals and non-renewals. We provide the necessary documentation and support to ensure your roof meets all insurance criteria, helping to prevent non-renewal notices based on roof age or condition.

Conclusion: Our Team is Here to Help

At RoofCrafters, we understand that protecting your home and investment is a top priority. We have over 30 years of experience serving homeowners in Georgia, South Carolina, and Florida. Need help? Click the button below and we look forward to seeing you soon!

Anthony Marzbanian

My name is Anthony, and I am the lead estimator of RoofCrafters’ Georgia/South Carolina division. The roof is the most important part of a structure, and people count on that to protect themselves and their families. That is one of the many reasons why I love my job and enjoy coming to work every day. The continuous training, honesty, and providing the customer with the Roofcrafters experience is what makes me the best in the business.