Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

Roof Replacement

St. Augustine on a Budget: Affordable Roofing Options for the Old City

June , 2023 | 8 min. read

By David Toth

standing metal roof on a sea foam color Florida home

Welcome to St. Augustine, or St. Augie as locals lovingly call it. This beautiful part of St. Johns County is rich in history but also in a sense of community that is palpable throughout the Old City. Here, our homes reflect our coastal lifestyle. Our homes and roofs tell stories of resilience against the unique challenges of our climate.

For three decades, RoofCrafters has been a key player in these tales. Installing, repairing, and maintaining countless roofs that can withstand the intense Florida sun. Along with the seasonal downpours, and the occasional hurricane. We know what it takes for a roof to stand tall in St. Augie's weather.

Victorian style home with red shingles

Navigating the wide variety of roofing materials can be daunting. Especially when you're looking for a blend of durability and affordability. After all, you want a roof that can shelter your home without making a big dent in your wallet. That's where this guide comes in. 

We're here to help you identify the best and most cost-effective roofing solutions for your home in St. Johns County. With our experience in the roofing industry, coupled with a thorough understanding of St. Augustine's climate.

In this article, we'll cover various types of roofing materials, focusing on cost-effectiveness. From asphalt shingles to the increasingly popular metal roofs. We aim to provide a comprehensive understanding of the available options. Whether you're a long-time resident of Florida's Historic Coast or a newcomer drawn in by the Old City's charm. Sit back and let us guide you through the realm of affordable roofing in St. Augustine.

Florida's Historic Coast Favorite: Why Asphalt Shingles Reign in St. Augie

 

Florida-style stucco home with new asphalt shingles

In the world of roofing materials. Asphalt shingles offer an excellent balance of affordability and durability. Particularly in our quaint St. Augustine and the wider St. Johns County region. Their popularity goes beyond being the most recognizable roofing type. Several reasons have sealed asphalt shingles' position as the undisputed favorite in the Old City.

White shingle roof on blue house in Florida

Let's start with the obvious: cost-effectiveness. Asphalt shingles boast one of the lowest initial installation costs in the roofing market. This makes them an excellent choice if you need a new roof without straining your budget. And the financial benefits don't stop there. Asphalt shingles have low maintenance requirements, sparing you from frequent expensive upkeep.

New call-to-action

Asphalt Shingles: More Than Affordable

 

Then comes versatility. Like chameleons, asphalt shingles adapt to their surroundings, available in a wide array of colors and styles. This variety will enable you to select a look that fits your curb appeal. One that'll complement the architectural style of your homes. Whether you're topping off a charming Spanish colonial revival or a modern Florida ranch. You'll find an asphalt shingle that matches perfectly.

two-story home with a new GAF Timberline UHDZ shingle in Pewter gray

A factor contributing to shingles' popularity in St. Augie is their suitability for our local climate. Shingles offer good resistance against the Florida sun's heat and handle our region's humidity quite well. While they may not be as hurricane-proof as some pricier roofing options. They're designed to stand up to the sporadic bouts of severe weather we experience in St. Johns County.

So, in asphalt shingles, you find a material that's affordable and well-equipped to handle St. Augustine's unique climate. But while asphalt shingles may rule the roost, they're far from the only game in town. In the next sections, we'll explore other cost-effective roofing options worth considering for your home.

New call-to-action

Metal Roofing: The Rising Star of Cost-Effective Options in St. Augustine

 

Metal roofing, while relatively new to the scene, is quickly making waves in the roofing landscape of St. Augustine. Although it hasn't overthrown asphalt shingles' reign. It's steadily establishing itself as a formidable, cost-effective alternative. Let's dive into why metal roofing might be your next top choice for your home in the Old City.

beautiful home with a flat and mansard roofline with metal slate shingles

Picture this: a roof that serves you loyally for decades, with little need for repair or maintenance attention. Sounds appealing, doesn't it? That's the long-term value that metal roofing offers. Ok, its initial cost surpasses that of asphalt shingles. But, the longevity of a metal roof could save you the expense of 2 or 3 replacement costs over time. In essence, a one-time investment in metal roofing provides peace of mind for years, if not decades.

Metal Roofing: Your Greatest Return on Investment

 

But it's not only durability that positions metal roofing as an emerging favorite. This roofing type is versatile. Much like asphalt shingles, metal roofs come in various colors and styles. Including those that mimic the look of traditional shingles or tiles. Thus, choosing a sturdy roof doesn't mean compromising on aesthetics.

large home with a screw-down metal roof in Jacksonville Florida

Don't overlook its suitability for our local St. Johns County climate either. Metal roofs are more than capable of standing their ground against our weather conditions. They reflect heat, aiding in keeping your home cool during our sweltering St. Augie summers. Furthermore, they're resilient in the face of severe storms. Providing impressive wind resistance and waterproofing capabilities.

blue-gray metal shingles on a 2-story hip and gable-style roof up close

Yes, asphalt shingles still wear the crown as the most affordable roofing material in St. Augustine. But metal roofing is a worthy contender to consider. Metal roofing demands a higher initial investment, but the long-term benefits could render it the right choice for your home. In the following sections, we'll dive deeper into these two materials. And hopefully, we can help you make a well-informed choice for your home on Florida's Historic Coast. Stick with us - the best is yet to come!

Selecting the Ideal Roof for Your St. Augustine Home

 

The decision to choose a specific roofing material depends on what you value the most. Is it cost-effective? Durability? Aesthetic appeal? By evaluating the pros and cons of the leading options, you can make a decision that aligns with your unique needs and budget.

Asphalt Shingles: Advantages, Disadvantages, and Cost

 

Seafoam color stucco with cultured stone and a GAF Timberline HDZ shakewood shingle roof

 

Pros:

  • Cost-effective
  • Diverse style options
  • Simple to install and repair

Cons:

  • Shorter lifespan compared to metal
  • Susceptible to weather-related damage

stucco home with brick accents - shingle roof, creating contrast and blending with the bricks - combo color scheme

Cost:

The cost of replacing a roof with asphalt shingles in St. Augustine will vary based on the size and complexity of the project. Here's the average cost of a shingle roof in St. Johns County:

  • 3-tab shingle roof: Average cost ranges from $7,500 to $11,000
  • Architectural shingles: Average cost ranges from $11,500 to $17,500
  • Upgraded architectural shingle: Average cost ranges from $13,500 to $19,500
  • Designer shingle roofs: Average cost ranges from $18,500 to $29,500

Please note, these are estimates and actual costs may vary.

Metal Roofing: Advantages, Disadvantages, and Cost

 

Galvalume standing seam metal roof

Pros:

  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Energy-efficient
  • Requires minimal maintenance

Cons:

  • Higher upfront cost
  • Installation requires skilled and experienced roofers

large split-level home with red aluminum standing seam metal roof

Cost:

The cost for a metal roof in St. Augustine varies depending on the type of metal used and the installation method. Here are the average costs:

  • Screw-down metal roofs: Average cost ranges from $17,000 to $32,500
  • Standing seam metal: Average cost ranges from $28,000 to $43,000

The savings in maintenance and replacement costs can make metal roofing a cost-effective choice.

Image call to action, use the pricing calculator to estimate the cost of your roof replacement

Remember, the most cost-effective roof isn't necessarily the one with the lowest upfront cost. It's the one that delivers the best value over its lifetime. Thus, both initial costs and long-term maintenance and replacement needs should be considered. This is why it's important to consult with an experienced roofing contractor. One who can guide you in making the best decision for your St. Augustine roof replacement.

Safeguarding Your Old City Home: Make the Best Choice with RoofCrafters

 

two Jacksonville Sales guys smiling with the team in the background doing field training

We understand that selecting a roof for your home goes beyond budget considerations. It's about providing an enduring, protective shield for your home. One that strikes the perfect balance between durability, aesthetics, and cost-effectiveness. Many of our clients have taken advantage of our financing options to secure a superior roof. We'd recommend considering financing as a viable alternative.

Your home is more than just a structure; it's a cherished space where you create memories. It deserves the best possible protection. Whether you choose asphalt shingles or an emerging alternative like metal roofing, we're here to guide you through the process. Your peace of mind and your home's safety in St. Johns County are our utmost priorities. So, why wait? Reach out to RoofCrafters today. Put our 30 years of roofing experience to work for you. Let's ensure your home is ready to weather any storm, come rain or shine, in St. Augustine, Florida.

image call to action, schedule an inspection

David Toth

My name is David Toth and I am the lead estimator in North Florida with RoofCrafters Roofing. Originally from New Brunswick, I have called Florida home for the past 47 years. I enjoy cooking along with traveling to different historical areas in Florida when I have free time.