Should You Repair or Replace Your Roof?

RoofCrafters: The one-stop solution to all your residential and commercial roofing needs.

Roofs often face pretty harsh weather conditions throughout the year, so it is natural for them to wear out over time. Even with regular maintenance and inspections, you will need to replace your roof at some point.


However, should you repair or replace your roof? Let’s find out!


Should You Repair or Replace Your Roof?


Like everything else, your roof has a certain life, after the useful life is over,  you need to have it replaced. While some materials are more premium and last longer than others, eventually, you need to replace your roof.


We’ll discuss when you should replace your roof below:




One of the key factors in determining whether you should replace your roof is its age. You should replace your roof when it nears the end of its expected lifespan, even if it appears to be in good condition.


Old roofs have a greater likelihood of failing and causing  leaking, which can cause high repair costs and even create more serious problems, such as harmful mold.


You should generally start looking for a new roof when it reaches the 15- 20 year mark if you have an asphalt shingle roof. Even insurance companies offer little or no coverage for roofs older than 15-20 years old. If you have invested in a premium roofing material such as metal roofing, you will not require roof replacements as often because metal roofing installed properly could last over 50 years.


Frequency of Repair


If your roof is developing leaks frequently, it indicates a problem with the roof or faulty installation, making it unsafe. We recommend contacting a credible roofing contractor to inspect the roof and have them explain what you need to do. This will save you time and money.

Read Now: How Long Do Roof Repairs Last And What Do They Cost?

Roofing Fact: 86% of roof leaks are caused by improper installation. And the average roofing contractor goes out of business in less than 3 years!

The Type of Damage


Some signs of damage show up inside the house on the ceiling, while others could be in the attic under the wood decking.  For example, if your ceiling keeps sagging, gets discolored, or the paint peels away repeatedly, you might have a roof leak that has caused severe damage and will require replacing the entire roof.


Other signs such as extensive granule loss might be visible on the roof’s surface and cause significant loss of life to the shingles. To prevent roof leaks from damaging the inside of your home, you might need a new roof.

A roof with cracks is a bad roof because it allows moisture, debris, and pests to enter your home which can often cost a lot of money to resolve. If your roof is cracked or has missing granules or curled shingles, you should call a roofer and get the roof inspected.


Any rust on the chimney flashing or rusted  roofing nails could  indicate that the roof is compromised and it may need to be replaced.


Improper Installation


Saving money on a roofing job is probably not the best idea. While it may seem like you are saving some money during installation, contractors charge according to their expertise and skillset. Cheap roof quote most often means cheap work.

An inexpensive contractor will get the job done for less money, but you are likely to pay more for repairs and maintenance in the long run. Remember, insurance does not cover improperly installed roofs.


The Extent of Damage


Regardless of how new your roof is, external factors such as strong winds, rain, hail, fallen tree limbs and fires can be extremely destructive. After any incident, call a roofer to examine the damage and they can guide you on your next steps.


A contractor should repair small damage such as strong winds blowing off a few shingles; however, large-scale damage requires you to replace the whole roof.


If you decide to repair extensive damage, it results in poor roof system integrity and increases the possibility of more problems down the line.


Your Maintenance Schedule


Depending on your maintenance schedule and how promptly you address repairs, you might need a replacement or roof repairs. Should you repair or replace your roof?


Here are a few things to consider:


1. When Was Your Last Inspection?


You should contact a roofer to inspect your roof bi-annually to check for any problems and address them promptly. Additionally, you should conduct visual inspections yourself to monitor any significant impact damage or mold growth to diagnose potential problems preemptively.


2. How Often Do You Clean Your Roof?


Debris accumulates on your roof and causes all sorts of problems. Not only does it trap water, but it also adds more weight to your roof, which can cause leaks.


Neglecting the gutters can be detrimental to your roof, so you should have them cleaned  out to remove any debris trapped inside them. Doing so prevents any blockages and allows the gutter to drain easily instead of pooling and backing up on your roof.


Read Now: Can a Roof be Repaired Instead of Replaced?

When Should You Repair Your Roof?


General wear leads to roof damage. Regardless of what type of roof you have, it is inevitable that you will need to call a contractor to repair it. If you notice any damage, you should invest in roof repairs because leaving problems unaddressed leads to higher repair costs in the long run.


However, we do not recommend opting for a budget contractor or conducting DIY repairs since both can be dangerous for your property, belongings, and the occupant’s lives.

Always invest in a credible and experienced roofer with a history of delivering great results.

Also Read: How Long Do Roof Repairs Last And What Do They Cost?

Did you know that 86% of roof leaks are caused by improper installation?

Need a New Roof or Repairs? We’re Here to Help!


Once you know whether you need a new roof or roof repair, you can call up RoofCrafters for help! However, we are also here to help if you cannot figure out if you need a new roof. Call to schedule an appointment with us and one of our highly trained estimators will come out to help you determine if you need a new roof or just a small roof repair.

With over 28 years of roofing experience and thousands of satisfied customers in Georgia, South Carolina, and Florida, we can assure you that when you pick RoofCrafters, you will be getting Professionalism, Demonstrated Integrity and The RoofCrafters Experience.


We are the one-stop-shop for all your roofing needs regardless of whether you need commercial or residential roofing. If you are confused about what type of roof materials would be the best for you or which level of warranty to choose from, then we are here to help!

So, should you replace or repair your roof? Call us now and we will help you decide!
Ready to get started?
Talk to one of our Roof specialists.                Schedule Free Inspection Now