Is it time for a new roof?! Choosing the right shingles for yours is a vital decision when it comes to protecting your home from the elements. Among the many options available, two popular choices are TAMKO shingles and GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles. TAMKO is known for its range of durable and aesthetically pleasing shingles, while GAF UHDZ Timberline shingles boast advanced technology for superior performance.
We know that even though there are many options, it can still be tricky to narrow it all down. Our family at RoofCrafters has replaced shingle roofing systems for nearly thirty years. Now we want to help you. That's why we're here! Both brands promise durability, weather resistance, and curb appeal, but understanding the differences between them is essential to make an informed decision for your roofing project.
In this comprehensive comparison, we'll explore the key features and benefits of these shingles to help you determine which is the best fit for your home. Let's dive into the roofing world and find the perfect option for your needs! Ready to begin?
TAMKO Shingles: The Basics
TAMKO is another competitor that manufactures shingles. In the roofing world, every contractor inevitably discovers a particular brand they love above the rest, similar to how you may have a preferred clothing item or favorite pair of shoes. While TAMKO may not be the favorite of many, it's still worth looking into when sorting through your options. If budget is a concern for you, this is one of your top picks.
.jpg?width=400&height=261&name=OIP%20(6).jpg)
This brand offers a wide range of shingles known for fulfilling the basic roofing needs of the homeowner. What does that mean? You're going to get what you pay for, which is a medium-grade shingle that'll do its job and not much beyond that. Here are some key aspects of TAMKO shingles:
Material and Durability of TAMKO Shingles
TAMKO shingles are made from a mix of fiberglass and asphalt. This combination gives them decent strength and resilience against harsh weather conditions. A typical roof from this line will last 10-15 years.
Styles and Designs Offered by TAMKO
TAMKO offers a variety of styles, colors, and textures to suit different architectural designs. Whether you prefer a traditional or modern look, TAMKO may have shingles to match your style. Click here to see what colors and styles are available to you based on your zip code.
Cost-Effectiveness of TAMKO Shingles
TAMKO shingles are often considered cost-effective, providing good roofing without breaking the bank. They offer a fair balance between price and durability. However, these shingles are known for being "middle of the road," which is a step down from competitors like GAF and CertainTeed.
So, what about the Heritage line? TAMKO prides its Heritage shingles on having "vivid color and dramatic style." Like GAF, you can go to their site and type in your zip code to find colors available. Click here to find out what they can offer you aesthetics-wise.
TAMKO Heritage Warranties
The Heritage shingles come with standard manufacturer warranties that are in effect at the point of purchase. To be honest TAMKO's warranties are not as good as the other shingle brands.
The warranty terms include:
- Full-Start Non-Prorated Warranty Period of 10 Years
- 110 MPH Standard Application Wind Warranty
- 130 MPH High Wind Application Warranty
- Limited Wind Warranty Term of 15 Years
- 120-Month Algae Cleaning Term
GAF comes out on top from a warranty perspective, with their warranty offerings exceeding TAMKO's. However, this manufacturer gets ratings in the "good" range from roofing contractors who install them daily and home inspectors who've seen it all.
TAMKO competes head-to-head with other top manufacturers like Owens Corning and GAF, but the other two have several advantages over this one. All in all, it's considered more of a "middle of the road" shingle.
Overall, TAMKO offers good quality and value at lower prices. TAMKO may be a good option for you when:
- You want to save money on comparable shingles.
- You plan to move in the next ten years and are okay with more limited warranties.
- Your preferred roofing contractor recommends TAMKO and gives you a solid workmanship warranty on the installation.
GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles: How Do They Compare?
GAF is a well-known manufacturing company established in the late 1800s. With the slogan "We protect what matters most," they're North America's leading roofing and waterproofing manufacturer.
GAF Timberline Ultra High Definition Shingles are renowned for their advanced technology and long-lasting performance. They're a true specimen of fantastic quality! Let's explore some key features:
Advanced Technology in GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles
GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles feature Advanced Protection Technology, providing excellent protection against harsh weather, including wind, rain, and hail. They provide an unlimited wind speed warranty. So if you live in Florida or the southeast, hurricane season is scary and your home needs to be prepared!
GAF UHDZs have the patented dual shadow line that gives the shingle more definition. The shingles are also 20% thicker, coupled with the dual shadow line and this shingle has massive curb appeal!
Energy Efficiency of GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles
These shingles are designed to reflect more sunlight and absorb less heat, contributing to energy efficiency and potentially lowering cooling costs. This is great for homeowners who are looking for an option that saves as much as possible over time,
Wide Range of Options with GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles
Similar to TAMKO, GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles come in various colors and styles to match your home's aesthetics. A note for both brands regarding color/style: the choices available to you are entirely based on your location. Some options may not show when you type in your zip code, which is a drawback, but there isn't much you can do as a homeowner to prevent it.
There are still plenty of fantastic options, regardless, though!
Head-to-Head Comparison: TAMKO and GAF
Now, let's do a side-by-side performance comparison of TAMKO shingles and GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles. We'll check shingle durability and weather resistance. Who has the best styles and costs? Energy efficiency? Let's cover this now!
Data and Statistics: Durability and Performance Comparison
When deciding between TAMKO Heritage and GAF UHDZ Timberline shingles, it's crucial to consider their durability and performance. Here, we present some data and statistics to help you understand how each brand holds up over time.
Lifespan and Longevity
- GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles: According to recent studies, GAF UHDZ Timberline shingles are renowned for their exceptional durability, boasting an impressive lifespan of up to 50 years. This makes them a long-term investment for homeowners seeking a roof that stands the test of time.
- TAMKO Heritage Shingles: In comparison, TAMKO Heritage shingles offer an average lifespan of 15 to 20 years. While they provide solid performance, they may require replacement sooner than their GAF counterparts.
Weather Resistance
- GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles: Designed with advanced protection technology, these shingles excel in resisting harsh weather conditions, including strong winds, heavy rains, and hail. They come with an unlimited wind speed warranty for 15 years under the Golden Pledge warranty, ensuring your home remains protected during extreme weather events.
- TAMKO Heritage Shingles: TAMKO shingles are also built to withstand various weather conditions, though they offer a standard wind warranty of 110 MPH and an extended warranty of 130 MPH for high wind applications. While reliable, they may not provide the same level of protection as GAF UHDZ shingles in extreme conditions.
Warranty Coverage
- GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles: GAF provides an industry-leading warranty, with a lifetime warranty on materials (50 years non-prorated), 30 years on algae resistance, and 30 years on workmanship under the Golden Pledge warranty. This comprehensive coverage underscores the brand's confidence in the product's longevity and performance.
- TAMKO Heritage Shingles: The standard warranty for TAMKO Heritage shingles includes a Full-Start Non-Prorated Warranty Period of 10 years, a Limited Wind Warranty Term of 15 years, and a 120-month Algae Cleaning Term. While robust, it falls short of GAF's extensive warranty offerings.
Consumer Ratings
- GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles: Consumer reports and reviews frequently highlight the high satisfaction rates among homeowners using GAF UHDZ Timberline shingles, often citing their durability and aesthetic appeal.
- TAMKO Heritage Shingles: TAMKO receives good ratings from contractors and homeowners for providing reliable, cost-effective roofing solutions. However, some reviews indicate a preference for higher-end brands when long-term performance is a primary concern.
By analyzing these data points, you can better understand the durability and performance differences between TAMKO Heritage and GAF UHDZ Timberline shingles, helping you make a well-informed decision for your roofing project.
Styles and Aesthetics: Which Brand Looks Better?
Both brands offer durable shingles, but GAF offers strong resistance from the elements that are worth bragging about! This manufacturer goes above and beyond to ensure their shingles offer the best of the best, and that's why they're renowned as a top brand.
TAMKO has shingles with many color variations if you are into the multi-color look. Their shingles are not as heavy or as thick as the GAF UHDZ but they still look great on a roof.
TAMKO's Multi-color design
Who has the Pop?
Both brands have a wide range of styles and colors, allowing you to choose based on your home's design. As mentioned above, those styles and color choices depend on where you live.
If you're looking for more of a color "pop," the UHDZ shingle will likely suit your fancy more due to the dual shadow line and thicker shingle.
Cost Comparison: Evaluating Value and Investment
TAMKO shingles are often considered more cost-effective, making them a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners.
While GAF costs more, they're still an excellent bang for your buck if longevity, curb appeal, and durability are important to you.
Remember, the better the quality, the more you pay. Is it worth it in the long run? For a brand like GAF, yes!
Energy Efficiency: Which Shingle Saves More?
GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles offer better energy efficiency, which can be a factor if you're aiming to reduce your energy consumption. However, when asphalt shingles are involved, you'll find that most options fall somewhere in the middle, as most roofing materials aren't truly "environmentally friendly."
Overall, the GAF UHDZ Timberline shingles beat TAMKO by quite a landslide; however, that doesn't mean TAMKO isn't still a great brand to use if you're on a budget and are looking for something mid-grade. You'll still get your money's worth for either manufacturer!
Budget and basic reliability = TAMKO.
Longevity, curb appeal, and durability (with great warranties) = GAF.
Making Your Decision: Which Shingle Brand Suits You Best?
So, what did we learn today?! Selecting the right shingles is essential for a strong and happy roof. TAMKO and GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles each have their advantages, so take the time to research and choose wisely with the help of a professional roofer. Never rush your decision and if you're having trouble deciding, make a list of the pros and cons of each brand you're considering. Thank us later.
Have trouble deciding? Don't worry, you have plenty of time! Consider what matters most to you: durability, style, cost, or energy efficiency. Both TAMKO and GAF UHDZ Timberline Shingles have their unique strengths, so weigh your priorities and make the choice that best suits your needs and budget. If you want a shingle that stands the test of time, however, GAF is never a bad choice.
If you live in one of our service areas, help is right around the corner! When you're ready, visit our contact page to connect with one of our friendly RoofCrafters representatives. We're thrilled about the opportunity to take on your roofing project!
